| Player | Team | Analysis |
| Mike Bibby | Hawks | Wasted perfect third rack with 2-of-10 finish. |
| Daequan Cook | Heat | Deserving winner had night's two highest rounds. |
| Danny Granger | Pacers | Missed entire 4th rack, and last four moneyballs. |
| Jason Kapono | Raptors | Shockingly average considering his past success. |
| Rashard Lewis | Magic | 2nd despite a combined 4-of-30 on first two racks. |
| Roger Mason | Spurs | Rare clutch misfire with miss on last moneyball. |
 |
ESPN Insider John Hollinger's grade: C |
