| Player | Team | Analysis |
| J.R. Smith | Nuggets | Late sub's dunks had power but lacked creativity. |
| Nate Robinson | Knicks | Krypto-Nate up to challenge; was Chandler's back? |
| Dwight Howard | Magic | Nate's face said it all -- side slam an all-timer. |
| Rudy Fernandez | Blazers | Gave Martin his 15, but got the shaft from judges. |
 |
ESPN Insider John Hollinger's grade: C |
