| Year | Result |
| 1998 | Arizona 23, Nebraska 20 |
| 1997 | Colorado St. 35, Missouri 24 |
| 1996 | Colorado 33, Washington 21 |
| 1995 | Kansas St. 54, Colorado St. 21 |
| 1994 | Michigan 24, Colorado St. 14 |
| 1993 | Ohio St. 28, BYU 21 |
| 1992 | Hawaii 27, Illinois 17 |
| 1991 | BYU 13, Iowa 13 |
| 1990 | Texas A&M 65, BYU 14 |
| 1989 | Penn St. 50, BYU 39 |
| 1988 | Oklahoma St. 62, Wyoming 14 |
| 1987 | Iowa 20, Wyoming 19 |
| 1986 | Iowa 39, San Diego St. 38 |
| 1985 | Arkansas 18, Arizona St. 17 |
| 1984 | BYU 24, Michigan 17 |
| 1983 | BYU 21, Missouri 17 |
| 1982 | Ohio St. 47, BYU 17 |
| 1981 | BYU 38, Washington St. 36 |
| 1980 | BYU 46, SMU 45 |
| 1979 | Indiana 38, BYU 37 |
| 1978 | Navy 23, BYU 16 |
