Wednesday, May 2 Updated: May 11, 1:22 PM ET '55 Browns' enjoyed Otto-matic success By Eddie Epstein Special to ESPN.com |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
If Otto Graham had made his first retirement stick, then the 1955 Cleveland Browns wouldn't have "happened." After leading the Browns to nine consecutive league championship games (including the All-American Football Conference) and an NFL title in 1954, Graham announced his retirement. However, as the Browns looked less than stellar in training camp and during the 1955 exhibition season, head coach Paul Brown convinced Graham to come back for one more season.
Although Graham's record as a quarterback is impeccable -- 10 seasons, 10 league championship games, and seven league titles (four AAFC, three NFL) -- his reputation is somewhat diminished because, unlike other quarterbacks of his era, Graham did not call the plays. Of course, in today's game, no quarterback calls his own plays. The facts are what they are, but consider the following: In his six NFL seasons, the Browns were 58-13-1. His 1950-55 passing rating of 78.2 looks average by today's standards, but in only one of those six seasons was the league rating over 60.0. (The 2000 NFL passing rating was 78.1.) Graham's teams won more consistently than just about any other in history and he was a very productive passer. By any definition, that is a great quarterback.
Graham made his retirement stick after 1955 and the Browns' record was just 5-7 in 1956. Of course, the Browns returned to glory with Jim Brown and company, but they still didn't win as often as they did under Otto Graham.
Eddie Epstein works as a consultant to major league baseball teams. He is the co-author, along with ESPN.com's Rob Neyer, of "Baseball Dynasties: The Greatest Teams of All Time." He has been a regular contributor to ESPN.com's baseball coverage and is a huge football fan. |
|