Keyword
NBA
Scores
Schedule
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Message Board
NBA en espanol
CLUBHOUSE


SHOP@ESPN.COM
NikeTown
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Monday, January 14
 
User feedback: Shaq at fault, but not completely

ESPN.com

Miller
Miller

O'Neal
O'Neal

Shaquille O'Neal faces an automatic one-game suspension for throwing a punch at Chicago's Brad Miller on Saturday. But he could end up getting much more when the league determines its penalty.

ESPN.com wanted to know what you thought about the potential suspension of Shaq and any other Shaq-Miller aftereffects.

Here is a sampling of your responses:


I love the guy, and I think he's the most dominant player in the NBA. But I am so sick of him crying about getting fouled all of the time. And I'm sick of him giving excuses about why he is a horrible free-throw shooter. ... He has to learn to expect the hard fouls; one, because he is the biggest guy in the league, and two, because he can not make foul shots and that is the most effective way to stop him. He needs someone to open his eyes for him.

Tim Dickson
Ohio


This has been brewing for several years. Since refs refuse to call the offensive foul on Shaq when he turns into his opponent to clear out room so he can bull you over and dunk, teams have turned to his weakness and will foul so he has to make foul shots. ... Shaq needs to understand that for all his trash talk, Superman tatoo and physical play, teams are going to come after his weakness (foul shooting). If you can't take the heat, get out of the paint!

Karl Weber
Littleton, Colo.


For quite some time now, the refs have allowed Shaq to bull his way on offense and, in turn, have allowed defenders to mug him ... For the good of the game they should call a foul if one occurs, with no regard for Shaq's size or overwhelming strength. A foul is a foul, PERIOD. Doing so would force Shaq to use more finesse and less brute force, as well as force defenders to actually make plays on the ball and not just on Shaq.

Troy Schilling
Ellendale, N.D.

If O'Neal gets anything less than a $500,000 fine it will be an injustice. David Stern set the standard with the half-million dollar fine he laid on Mark Cuban. If harsh words merit that large of a fine, one would think that taking a swing would merit at least as large of a fine. If not, Stern will prove that: 'Shaq's swings may break some bones, but Mark Cuban's words really scare him.'
Matt,
Dallas


Let's ask coach Rudy Tomjanovich what he thinks about Shaq's behavior and how that kind of behavior affected his playing career. I am sure that he would have an opinion.

Sue Saunders
Central Point, Ore.


I can think of several other players that are fortunate Shaq has been patient the last 10 years. While Shaq's behavior is unexcusable, the NBA and the referees bear some of the blame for the beating he takes on a nightly basis. Brad Miller could have seriously injured Shaq with his flagrant foul and should also be suspended significantly as an example.

Ken Hanscom
Los Angeles


I think that it should be his intention, not the results, that dictates the fine. Whether or not he landed that punch is trivial (not to Miller, of course).

Nathan Wulff
Cedar Rapids, Iowa


Shaq doesn't just get abused, he abuses people every night. He runs over people, throws elbows to the head and refs simply don't call it. If he wants to be a role model with his movies and hanging with the stars, he needs to be held accountable. It was completely unacceptable, his uncontrolled rage. Tens of thousands of kids are watching to see if Shaq will get away with this. Let's give them the correct answer.

Tim Day
Toronto, Ontario

How did Shaq miss with that haymaker? Miller was standing right in front of him and wasn't even looking! Is there any correlation between this and Shaq's errant free throw shooting? AIR BALL!
Scott Schueler,
Dallas


There is no excuse for what Shaq did. He bumps into and knocks more people down than anyone else in the game. If he wants to stop being fouled all the time all he has to do is start hitting a decent percent of his free throws... Not only would he not get fouled as often, he would be leading the league in ppg, no questions asked! He deserves anywhere from a 5 to 7 game suspension (to practice his free throws)

Ryan Kuehl
New Brighton, Minn.


It bothers me that somehow Shaquille O'Neal is being portrayed as the victim in this situation. For as physical of a game as he plays, he needs to expect to be played physically himself.

Paul Linenfelser
Thousand Oaks, Calif.


It had to come to Shaquille defending himself, because no official could, or would, stop the carnage. Discraceful.

Michael Irwin
Orange, Calif.


The guy gets grabbed, hacked and attacked every game. I would have cracked a long time ago. Shaq has shown great restraint over the years. Shaq, I got your back!

DeVonne Milton
North Bay Ontario, Canada


If he wants to avoid them then he should improve his free-throw shooting, then there will be no Hack-a-Shaq.

Naveed Razvi
Chicago


Yes it was a punch, yes it was wrong, but Brad Miller deserved it. I'm surprised Shaq hasn't done that earlier because everyone mugs him. The officals need to control the game. Maybe we can ask Mark Cuban about this one?

Chase Kurinskas
West Bridgewater, Mass.

He should get one game for throwing the punch, a couple additional games for hitting someone in the back and he should be castrated for punching like a girl.
Hayes,
Philadelphia


If Mark Cuban can be fined $500,000 for bashing officials, Shaq should be given a huge fine. All too often players get away with throwing punches and only getting fined $20,000. To me, throwing a punch at a fellow player calls for a much heavier fine than bashing the head of officiating.

Brad Weismann
Dallas


If someone kept on fouling me and was talking smack at the beginning of the game I would have done the same thing Shaq did. What would you do?

Brian Shear
Gainesville, Fla.


No matter how big he is, he is human after all -- just like anyone else. I admire him for he has kept his cool all these years with all the hacking that he gets every game.

Christina Malicse
Los Angeles





 More from ESPN...
May: Postfight, Shaq not the only lucky one
Shaquille O'Neal could have ...
Rage review: NBA looking at Shaq-Miller fight
If his first punch had ...


AUDIO/VIDEO
Video
 L.A. Lakers vs. Chicago
Shaquille O'Neal retaliates against the Hack-a-Shaq approach with a little "Shaq-Fu" of his own.
avi: 2768 k
Standard | Cable Modem

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story